The choice of boundary conditions depends on the structure and the application.
If Periodic is checked, DiffuDict assumes that the structure is periodically repeated in the diffusion direction. If Symmetric (Dirichlet) is checked, a constant concentration is ensured along both border planes in the diffusion direction. For non-periodic structures, Symmetric (Dirichlet) boundary conditions give more accurate results then Periodic boundary conditions.
In previous versions of GeoDict, the computational memory requirements for Symmetric (Dirichlet) boundary conditions case were almost two times higher and therefore, the computational time was longer. This is no longer the case since GeoDict 2022.
For structures with large porosity (>80%), the difference between these two cases is insignificant and can be compared with a computational error.
In few situations, however, due to the structure’s geometry, using Dirichlet boundary conditions is unavoidable. An example, with pores artificially closed by using a periodic boundary condition, is shown below. When repeating the structure periodically it becomes clear, that periodic boundary conditions cannot be used in this case because the periodic repetition artificially closes the pores, reducing the true diffusivity. The use of Dirichlet boundary conditions eliminates this artifact.
|